
Prime Minister Mark Carney is not ruling out an Alberta immigration deal that would hand the province greater authority over who settles there, potentially along the lines of the arrangement Ottawa struck with Quebec in the early 1990s. Asked on Wednesday, October 21, 2026, whether a similar agreement could be reached with Alberta, Carney answered in French with a brief “We’ll see,” a response that signals openness without making any commitment.
The comments came a day after Alberta Premier Danielle Smith spoke with Carney about the results of a provincial referendum on immigration. Preliminary figures released Wednesday showed that about 53% of voters, just over one million Albertans, supported a question calling for more provincial control over immigration in order to bring newcomer numbers down to what the question described as “sustainable levels.” Official results are expected later next week.
What Carney and Smith Said
At a news conference in Calgary on Wednesday, Smith said she had told the prime minister that her government is preparing a “proposal” for Ottawa. She added that Alberta has been drawing “inspiration” from the 1991 Canada-Quebec accord as it develops its plan.
Carney, for his part, emphasized that Quebec occupies a unique position because of its distinct language and culture. He said Ottawa will also hold discussions with other provinces about immigration levels. Speaking in English, he said the federal government has “retaken control” of immigration and is listening to provincial concerns, while stressing that it will not move away from overall levels that are sustainable. As reported according to The Canadian Press, via Global News, he added that the government is bringing numbers down to that level now.
How the Quebec Model Works
The Canada-Quebec accord was signed in 1991, in the wake of the failed Meech Lake constitutional accord. Under the agreement, Quebec gained the power to set its own targets for economic immigration and to select many of the newcomers who settle in the province. The federal government retains responsibility for areas such as admissibility, security screening and citizenship.
An Alberta immigration deal modelled on that framework would represent a meaningful shift in how Canada manages population growth. Other provinces already participate in selecting some economic immigrants through provincial nominee programs, but the Quebec arrangement goes considerably further. Whether Ottawa would be willing to extend comparable powers to another province, and how such a deal would interact with national targets, remains an open question.
The Political Debate Over Immigration Levels
The issue has become a flashpoint in federal politics. Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, speaking in Calgary on Tuesday, said “immigration is totally out of control” and argued that provinces should have more say over intake because they are responsible for delivering many of the services newcomers rely on, such as health care and education.
Poilievre also took aim at comments Carney made to The New York Times, in which the prime minister said the next question is when to “resume some controlled increase in the population.” A federal Conservative fundraising email argued that immigration should be “dramatically reduced” rather than ramped back up. Immigration Minister Lena Diab did not respond to reporters’ questions on Wednesday.
Federal immigration targets are due to be updated next month. Ottawa had previously planned to raise permanent resident admissions to 500,000 a year, but it scaled back those targets in its 2024-2025 plan. The most recent plan calls for 385,000 permanent resident admissions this year and 370,000 in both 2027 and 2028.
Why an Alberta Immigration Deal Matters for the Economy
Immigration has been one of the most important drivers of Canadian economic growth in recent years, adding workers, consumers and taxpayers at a time when the population is aging. Alberta in particular has relied on newcomers and interprovincial migrants to fill jobs in energy, construction, health care and other sectors. Any change in how many people the province admits could affect labour availability and wage pressures for employers.
For investors, population growth feeds directly into demand for housing, retail spending and services. Slower immigration tends to ease pressure on rents and home prices, which could benefit renters and first-time buyers, but it can also cool demand for new construction and weigh on companies that depend on a growing customer base. Banks, homebuilders, real estate investment trusts and consumer-facing businesses with significant Alberta exposure would all be sensitive to a major policy shift.
There are also fiscal implications. Provinces fund many of the public services that newcomers use, so greater control over intake could help Alberta align population growth with its capacity in schools, hospitals and infrastructure. At the same time, a smaller labour force can limit overall economic expansion and the tax base that supports those services.
What Comes Next
The immediate next steps are Alberta’s formal proposal and the federal government’s updated immigration levels plan. Investors and businesses should watch whether Ottawa signals a willingness to negotiate a bilateral framework with Alberta, and whether other provinces push for similar powers. A patchwork of provincial immigration regimes would add complexity for employers recruiting internationally.
The timing also matters. Official referendum results are due later next week, and the federal levels plan is expected next month, so the coming weeks will reveal how far Ottawa is prepared to go. Carney has drawn a clear line on keeping overall national levels sustainable, which suggests any arrangement with Alberta would likely operate within federal totals rather than outside them. Businesses that rely on foreign workers, particularly in sectors facing labour shortages, may want to plan for a period of policy uncertainty while the two governments negotiate.
Conclusion
Carney’s noncommittal “We’ll see” leaves plenty of room for negotiation, but it confirms that an Alberta immigration deal is now on the federal agenda. With a majority of Alberta voters backing more provincial control and national targets already being trimmed, the debate over how fast Canada’s population should grow is likely to shape housing markets, labour supply and economic growth in the months ahead.