
Most Canadian investors believe their portfolios are well spread out, but a new survey suggests many may be more concentrated than they realize, both because of a persistent Canadian home bias and because of growing concentration inside global stock indexes. The findings, highlighted on October 23 by BNN Bloomberg personal finance columnist Dale Jackson, point to a gap between how diversified investors feel and how diversified they actually are.
The survey was commissioned by Picton Investments and carried out by Pollara Strategic Insights. It found that 83 per cent of Canadian investors are confident their portfolios are well diversified. Yet only 57 per cent said they were familiar with a structural shift in global equity markets, in which a shrinking number of companies make up an increasing share of major indexes such as the S&P 500.
A Confidence Gap Among Investors
The report argues that many investors are unaware of the risk that comes from a small group of very large companies, many of them tied to technology and artificial intelligence, carrying growing weight in benchmark indexes. That matters because those indexes are the yardsticks for many mutual funds and exchange-traded funds.
According to the survey, Canadian investors hold mainly mutual funds, at 55 per cent, and ETFs, at 31 per cent. Both types of products are often marketed as diversified solutions. But if the underlying benchmark is dominated by a handful of companies, a fund that tracks it closely may carry more concentration risk than its label suggests.
How Canadian Home Bias Shapes Portfolios
Diversification, at its core, means spreading money across sectors, regions and asset classes so that a downturn in one area does not sink an entire portfolio. On that measure, many Canadians fall short close to home. A 2024 Vanguard report cited in the column found that Canadian portfolios are about 18 times overweight in Canadian holdings.
Canadian securities make up roughly half of the typical Canadian portfolio, even though Canada accounts for less than three per cent of the global market. That imbalance is the essence of Canadian home bias: a tendency to favour familiar domestic companies over a far larger universe of opportunities abroad.
The issue is compounded by the makeup of the domestic market itself. Roughly two-thirds of stocks listed on the TSX are in the finance and resources sectors, and the top 10 holdings account for more than 38 per cent of the S&P/TSX composite index, compared with about 12 per cent for the global market. A portfolio weighted heavily toward Canada can therefore end up concentrated in a narrow set of industries.
Progress, but Still a Long Way to Go
There is some good news. Vanguard data show that Canadian home bias has eased from 67 per cent in 2012. Jackson suggests part of the historical tilt may trace back to rules in place before the 1990s, when foreign holdings in RRSPs were capped at 30 per cent. Even with that restriction long gone, old habits have been slow to change.
Vanguard’s balanced benchmark for Canadian investors calls for about 30 per cent in Canadian equities and 70 per cent in international equities. Jackson notes that some investors, such as snowbirds who plan to spend retirement income abroad, may need a different mix depending on where and in what currency they expect to spend their money.
Three Ways to Invest Beyond Canada
Jackson outlines three broad routes for adding foreign exposure. The first is global and international mutual funds, which can range from broad worldwide funds to those focused on regions excluding Canada and the U.S., or on specific countries or sectors such as technology. These are usually actively managed, and annual fees can exceed three per cent, a cost that comes directly out of returns.
The second option is global ETFs. These are passively managed and track a set formula, often based on market capitalization. They are less able to adjust to conditions in particular markets, but they tend to be far cheaper, with some unhedged foreign ETFs charging less than 0.05 per cent a year. Market-weighted ETFs are also more transparent than most mutual funds, since their holdings follow a published rule.
The third route is buying U.S.-listed stocks directly. Most Canadian brokerage accounts provide access to major American exchanges, and roughly half of the world’s publicly traded companies are based in the United States, many of which earn revenue around the globe. Readers can find the full breakdown in Dale Jackson’s column for BNN Bloomberg.
Watch the Hidden Cost of Currency
Jackson also flags a risk many investors overlook: the cost of dealing in foreign currencies. Currency-hedged versions of foreign funds generally cost more than their U.S.-dollar counterparts. He suggests that investors consider buying foreign equities in U.S. dollars and holding U.S. cash within registered accounts such as RRSPs and TFSAs, which can help limit repeated conversion costs.
At the same time, diversifying abroad should not mean swapping one concentration for another. Jackson’s advice is to spread foreign holdings across a wide range of sectors and regions, rather than leaning too heavily on the U.S. technology giants that already dominate many global benchmarks.
Before making changes, investors may want to look under the hood of the funds they already own. Fund fact sheets and ETF holdings lists show the largest positions and sector weights, which can reveal overlap between products that seem different on the surface. Someone holding a Canadian equity fund, a U.S. index fund and a global fund could find the same handful of large companies appearing again and again.
Conclusion
The Picton-Pollara survey shows a striking mismatch between confidence and reality. Most Canadian investors feel well diversified, yet Canadian home bias, a concentrated domestic market and top-heavy global indexes can leave portfolios more exposed than they appear. Reviewing geographic and sector weightings, understanding what funds actually hold and keeping an eye on fees and currency costs can help investors build portfolios that are genuinely diversified rather than merely labelled that way.